Monday, January 24, 2011
Fatwa of the Day #9
Ladies, if you are considering converting to Islam—a decision I encourage you to make; for all the advantages you gain from being a woman in Islam—I recommend you read the following Fatwa which will make you think twice before visiting your beauty parlor again.
As always, the Egyptian Dar al-Ifta (Arabic for the “Home of Fatwa Issuing”), succeeded at making me shake my head in disbelief and laugh at the same time.
The following inquiry was submitted to their website urging them to advise on this extremely critical matter:
The Question: Is plucking one’s eyebrows considered a sin for Muslim women?
The Answer(s):
- According to one group of scholars: YES, IT IS DEFINETELY A SIN! Plucking one’s eyebrows and/or the eyebrows of another woman is absolutely prohibited in Islam. In order to back this ruling, Dr. Ali Goma Mohammed, the wise Muslim scholar who responds to these important questions—in the form of Fatwas, refers to the following saying in the Hadith:
Allah curses the women who perform tattoos, get tattos, the women who pluck the eybrows of others, and those women who get their eyebrows plucked, and part their teeth for adornment, who change Allah’s creation.
- the other group advocates for the following: If a woman is unmarried she is prohibited from plucking her eyebrows. On the other hand a married woman is permitted to do so on the conditions that her husband gives her permission, and that she does it for adornment purposes only (i.e. she plucks her eyebrows to make herself prettier and more attractive to her husband).
Having read that, I believe that unmarried young Muslim women who are going to remain celibate for quite some time, and who dislike their bushy eyebrows should simply get used to it. And who knows, maybe one day “unibrowness” might become the next fashion sensation!
Comments (13)

Sort by: Date Rating Last Activity
Post a new comment
Comments by IntenseDebate
Reply as a Guest, or login:
Go back
Connected as (Logout)
Not displayed publicly.
Connected as (Logout)
Not displayed publicly.
Posting anonymously.
Thee · 740 weeks ago
FTLebanon 41p · 740 weeks ago
NFQ 48p · 740 weeks ago
Also, what does it mean to "part [one's] teeth for adornment"? I can't figure out if that refers to a large smile, or some sort of anti-orthodontics.
FTLebanon 41p · 740 weeks ago
I tried to look up what is meant by "part their teeth for adornment", but couldn't find anything. So I checked the Arabic version of this Hadith; and after painstakingly trying to figure out what was meant by this expression, I was able to make sense of it.
The English translation is actually correct, by "parting" the teeth, it is meant to artificially create a gap between the central incisors. This was done for two reasons: First, because it was considered attractive; the second reason older women used to "part" their teeth was to bluff men into thinking they are young; young people have natural gaps between the incisors, because haven't grown their 3rd mollars (wisdom tooth) yet.
So, according to this Hadith, parting one's teeth—which was done using a metal filer— is prohibited.
AndrewHall 95p · 740 weeks ago
Lucian Vâlsan · 737 weeks ago
I have been reading some of your articles and I am frankly surprised (in a good way) that reasonable people exist even in countries where fundamentalism is a state policy.
Unfoortunately, my country also is heading to this, but on the orthidox-christian fundamentalism.
However, I am writing this comment in order to advise you on translating to English some of your sources and specially what you're going to crticize.
I would have wanted to read that inquiry but it is in Arabic and I can't read nor can I understand the Arabic language.
Anyway, keep up the good work!
Lucian Vâlsan, Cluj Napoca, Romania.
Carla · 701 weeks ago
I am just giving you an advice..thanks.
carla · 701 weeks ago
carla · 701 weeks ago
carla · 701 weeks ago
amin · 696 weeks ago
So if you are going to question what you consider authentic (as per scholary conclusion across the world) then you must essential also question other hadith and then the very dogmatic practice of Islam as we know will for the most part be questioned and lose their validity. It is like scholars today who seek to create doubt about underage brides (children) when there are at least 3 sahih ahadith collection by the leading ahadith compilers such as Bukhari, Muslim and Dawud stating child brides are permitted forget thet they by doing so open the gateway (which most havent caught on to as of yet blinded by the sheep syndrome not allowing for critical or independent thinking let alone interpretation) will other ahadith to be questions as well. And that will choke the power hold these scholars enjoy on the common muslim.
amin · 696 weeks ago
That simple. So this attempt to discredit the blog owner is just absurd. I suggest if you have a problem, then there is nothing stopping you from contacting Sheik Gomaa.
A funny observation nowadays is though, that most scholars dont care whether the girl dress likes whores or nuns, as long as they cover their hair. The really funny thing is that all beauty (other than that naturall present) is only for the husbands eyes. So the very successful and compettive attempts by majority of the scarf bearing girls to follow fashion trends and vanity is against Islam - as per the Quran. A guy will turn more heads after a girl who plucks her eyebrows to form the perfect and prettiest of brows with skin tight fashionable outfits, piles of makeup and of course the bling and the perfume aroma than he would after a nun with bushy eyebrow, plain face and humble and neutral attire not emphasizing her curves.
amin · 696 weeks ago
Fatwas are funny yet dangerous. They have power because majority have chosen to give the authors of fatwas such power and chokehold. No room for critical thinking and independent and alternative interpretations because that will create a loss of power. But the blind can not see and the dead not hear. So eloquently expressed in the Quran.
People complain about people who post these fatwas. Have the guts to instead complaint directly to those who issue such fatwas. Egypt enjoys a very high position as far as fatwa issuing and islamic teaching is concerned. Up until late 1990s Al Azhar the most prestige and strong of all institutions where people go to from across the world, kept issuing fatwas allowing female circumcision. Until recent laws passed in Egypt the practice was considered Sunnah. Not obligatory but honourable for the woman as per - what do you know - Sahih ahadith. So there you go.